Bail Hearing Lawyer in Montreal
The first hours after an arrest are decisive. The bail hearing determines whether the accused will await trial at home or in custody. Me Mahmoud acts quickly to prepare a solid release plan and argue it before the court.
What we do for you
- Urgent assistance at the police station and advice before the first appearance
- Negotiating a consent release with the Crown
- Preparing sureties and a complete release plan
- Arguing the bail hearing (s. 515 Cr.C.)
- Reverse-onus cases (s. 515(6) Cr.C.)
- Review of a detention order before the Superior Court (s. 520 Cr.C.)
- Applications to vary overly strict conditions
- Youths detained under the YCJA
Why choose Mahmoud Avocats
In Canadian law, release is the rule. Section 11(e) of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms guarantees the right not to be denied reasonable bail without just cause. Pre-trial detention must remain the exception. In practice, the outcome of a bail hearing often depends on the quality of the plan presented to the judge: a stable address, credible sureties, real supervision and conditions tailored to the Crown's concerns. Me Mahmoud starts building that plan from the first call, contacts the family to identify sureties and gathers the supporting documents. When the Crown opposes release, he argues the hearing with the rigour of a lawyer used to appellate courts, including the Supreme Court of Canada.
View Me Mahmoud's full profileTimelines: what happens after an arrest
After an arrest, the police may release the person on an undertaking to appear, sometimes with conditions. If they keep the person in custody, he or she must be brought before a judge within 24 hours where a judge is available (s. 503 Cr.C.). This first appearance often takes place by video from the police station or detention centre, including on weekends and holidays. At the appearance, the Crown states whether it consents to release or opposes it. It may ask to adjourn the bail hearing, but not for more than three clear days without the accused's consent (s. 516(1) Cr.C.). The defence may also ask for a short delay to finalize its plan and bring its sureties, which is often better than a hearing argued too quickly.
The three grounds for detention (s. 515(10) Cr.C.)
Detention is only justified if the Crown establishes at least one of the following grounds: 1. Primary ground: detention is necessary to ensure the accused attends court. 2. Secondary ground: it is necessary for the protection or safety of the public, including victims and witnesses, having regard to a substantial likelihood of reoffending or interfering with the administration of justice. 3. Tertiary ground: it is necessary to maintain confidence in the administration of justice. The court considers the apparent strength of the Crown's case, the gravity of the offence, the circumstances of its commission and the potential for a lengthy prison term. In R. v. St-Cloud, 2015 SCC 27, the Supreme Court held that this ground is not reserved for exceptional crimes, which is why it must be answered in a structured way.
Burden of proof and reverse-onus situations
As a rule, the Crown must justify detention. The judge must also apply the principle of restraint and the ladder principle: the least onerous form of release is considered first, and every condition must be necessary and reasonable (R. v. Antic, 2017 SCC 27; R. v. Zora, 2020 SCC 14). In some situations the onus is reversed and the accused must show why detention is not justified (s. 515(6) Cr.C.). This applies, for example, when the offence was allegedly committed while on release, to certain weapons, drug trafficking and organized crime offences, and to certain intimate partner violence offences. Since July 15, 2026, the Bail and Sentencing Reform Act (Bill C-14) has expanded these situations, including violent auto theft, home invasion break-ins, violent extortion and assaults or sexual assaults involving choking or strangulation. It also provides that the ladder principle does not apply in reverse-onus cases. These files require a particularly thorough plan.
Building a convincing release plan
A good plan answers the court's concerns directly. Depending on the case, it may include: • one or more sureties who know the accused well, are willing to supervise and pledge an amount of money; • a fixed address, sometimes away from the complainant; • a curfew, a no-contact order or a ban on attending certain places; • proof of employment, studies or enrolment in therapy; • surrender of a passport when flight risk is raised. A cash deposit is only required exceptionally. Note also that since Bill C-14, a person convicted of an indictable offence in the last ten years cannot act as a surety unless no other suitable surety is available and it is in the interests of justice. Sureties must therefore be chosen carefully.
If bail is denied
A detention order is not final. The defence may apply for a review before a Superior Court judge (s. 520 Cr.C.), particularly where the first judge erred in law, where the decision is clearly inappropriate or where relevant new evidence is presented, such as a new surety or a treatment placement (R. v. St-Cloud). When detention continues, the Criminal Code also provides for a review hearing after 90 days (s. 525 Cr.C.; R. v. Myers, 2019 SCC 18). For murder and other section 469 offences, the bail application is made directly to the Superior Court (s. 522 Cr.C.).
Frequently asked questions
How long can my loved one be held before seeing a judge?
A detained person must be brought before a judge within 24 hours where a judge is available. If the Crown asks to adjourn the bail hearing, the adjournment cannot exceed three clear days without the accused's consent.
Do we have to pay cash bail?
Usually not. Most often, the surety promises to pay an amount if the accused breaches the conditions, without paying anything up front. A cash deposit is only required in exceptional cases.
Who can act as a surety?
A reliable adult who knows the accused well and can supervise him or her: a parent, spouse, employer or close friend. The surety must understand the responsibilities involved. Since July 2026, a person convicted of an indictable offence in the last ten years normally cannot be a surety.
Should my loved one explain his or her side of the story to the judge?
No. A bail hearing is not the trial. The accused may not be questioned about the offence (s. 518(1)(b) Cr.C.) and should not discuss the facts with the police, with other detainees or on detention centre phones, since calls may be recorded.
What if bail is denied?
A review can be sought before the Superior Court, especially if new elements strengthen the release plan. An automatic review is also provided after 90 days in custody.
What happens if a condition is breached?
Breaching a condition can lead to a new charge (s. 145 Cr.C.), arrest and a new hearing where the onus is on the accused. If a condition is unrealistic, it is better to apply to vary it than to risk a breach.
Need immediate help?
A loved one has just been arrested and is about to appear? Call now, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
514-601-2404Criminal emergencies 24/7 — phone, email, text and WhatsApp
Articles récents
Arrêté pour alcool au volant : quoi faire dans les premiers jours
Permis suspendu 90 jours, véhicule saisi, date de cour : les gestes à poser et les erreurs à éviter dans les jours suivant une arrestation.
Lire l'articleMon conjoint veut retirer sa plainte : est-ce possible ?
En violence conjugale, la personne plaignante ne peut pas retirer sa plainte elle-même. Qui décide, ce qu'elle peut faire et ce qu'il faut éviter.
Lire l'articleAccusé de vol à l'étalage : que faire ?
Arrêté pour un vol à l'étalage ? Vos droits face à l'agent de sécurité, la lettre du magasin, le tribunal et les façons d'éviter un casier judiciaire.
Lire l'article